Big Ideas
Aine Seitz McCarthy
  • Blog
  • About

Charter schools are like Italian restaurants

6/14/2013

3 Comments

 
A great article from Slate on charter schools and a thought-provoking response from an English teacher at a  Chicago charter school:

The way we have to teach in charters, for the most part, is skill based...This means that in a "writing" class, I am basically teaching basic grammar and how to approach the English section of a standardized test. With all of the "skills" that I have to teach and assess in a year there is barely time to teach things that I think would actually help get kids interested in writing, things like figurative language and creative writing.

Some people, and I think I mostly agree with them, think that this inherently shows the inequality of the education system. For instance, you would never hear an argument that students at New Trier
need more "skill based" instruction because it is assumed that students who attend New Trier already have those skills when they enter the school.

We have also noticed with our students that we shelter them so much, and make them adhere to such rigorous standards, that they often struggle once they leave the charter model (even on full ride scholarships to four-year colleges). They have a hard time developing ideas on their own and being self-disciplined without all of the structures we have in place to try to teach them to be self-disciplined. My school is now trying to incorporate teaching (and assessing, naturally) character strengths to students to try to combat this problem. Sigh. I don't know what the answer is...

Hat tips: JMM & NAJ
3 Comments
Emilia
6/18/2013 03:31:01 pm

I somehow missed the Italian restaurant connection..?

Reply
ainesmccarthy@gmail.com
6/19/2013 01:57:16 am

It's in the slate article. They are both good but not generalizably so.

Reply
Emilia
6/19/2013 09:56:00 am

Sweet.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Aine Seitz McCarthy

    International development, economics and some pretty ambitious ideas from a stubborn graduate student clinging to her sense of adventure.


    Categories

    All
    Agriculture
    Amusements
    Books
    Camp
    Demography
    Economics
    Education
    Family Planning
    Fieldwork
    Futball
    Gender
    Grad School
    International Development
    News
    Public Policy
    Research
    Travel

    RSS Feed

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.