Big Ideas
Aine Seitz McCarthy
  • Blog
  • About

On the health care brain drain

1/1/2012

2 Comments

 
Picture
Loss of doctors to destination countries, compared with burden of HIV in nine African source countries. Size of each bubble represents ratio of estimated compounded lost investment over gross domestic product, and y axis corresponds to ratio of doctors working in target countries and doctors currently working domestically.
Do developed countries drain all the health workers trained abroad? And what is the impact of this?

Michael Clemens of CGE wrote a feisty response on Blattman's blog to the notion that doctors are being stolen from poor countries. Additionally, Katie Leach-Kemon, at IHME, sent me a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis of human capital loss of doctors trained in Africa and working in developed countries. I'm trying to synthesize the two.

Clemens is certainly right that medical staff are perfectly active agents that  have just as much right to emigrate as any other expat. The question remains, however, whether or not Clemens' $6,000 per year in remittances sent from the US to Africa is actually any legitimate compensation for losing a health worker.  This human capital analysis indicates that the cost of educating a health worker in their home countries, across various African countries, varies from $21,000 to $59,000. These numbers grow significantly when you consider loss of return on investment (without consideration for remittances). However, its difficult to compare costs and benefits when human capital costs are public and remittances are sent to private family members.

Additionally, the human capital analysis assumes that health workers leave their home country immediately following training, while Clemens finds the average African-trained member of the American Medical Association left his or her home country well over five years after earning their MD. Does this make up for the loss of human capital? Probably not.

The human capital analysis concludes that because they are benefiting from medical staff trained abroad, "destination countries should consider investing in measurable training for source countries and strengthening of their health systems."  While investing in health care human capital is beneficial, I'm not sure this is the most efficient solution.  In the U.S., some medical schools provide incenstives for doctors to work in rural regions or states though medical school loan forgiveness. Some market mechanisms in developing countries may provide more reasons and incentives for and African-trained doctor to stay in Africa and fulfill that return on investment.
2 Comments
CBT
1/5/2012 05:00:06 am

I have so many thoughts on this! We must talk in person/phone. Or you should come sit in on my class next week when I lecture on it/the students debate on it!

Reply
Aine
1/5/2012 05:08:19 am

I WISH! Fly me out as a guest speaker?? This is a huge topic and I only know a tiny slice of it.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Aine Seitz McCarthy

    International development, economics and some pretty ambitious ideas from a stubborn graduate student clinging to her sense of adventure.


    Categories

    All
    Agriculture
    Amusements
    Books
    Camp
    Demography
    Economics
    Education
    Family Planning
    Fieldwork
    Futball
    Gender
    Grad School
    International Development
    News
    Public Policy
    Research
    Travel

    RSS Feed

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.